Google’s massive book-scanning project has been declared legal

TECHi's Author Michio Hasai
Opposing Author Reuters Read Source Article
Last Updated Originally published October 16, 2015 · 8:20 PM EDT
Reuters View all Reuters Two Takes by TECHi Read the original story Published October 16, 2015 Updated January 30, 2024
TECHi's Take
Michio Hasai
Michio Hasai
  • Words 92
  • Estimated Read 1 min

When Google started scanning tens of millions of books in order to make them available online, authors from across the globe were naturally a little upset. Actually, they were really upset, enough that a group of them sued the company back in 2008 on the grounds that Google was violating copyright laws and was depriving them of money. Unfortunately for them, the 2nd United States Circuit Court of Appeals in New York didn’t agree, and declared earlier this week that Google Books is a perfectly legal project that meets “fair use” rules. 

Reuters

Reuters

  • Words 203
  • Estimated Read 2 min
Read Article

A U.S. appeals court ruled on Friday that Google’s massive effort to scan millions of books for an online library does not violate copyright law, rejecting claims from a group of authors that the project illegally deprives them of revenue. The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York rejected infringement claims from the Authors Guild and several individual writers, and found that the project provides a public service without violating intellectual property law. The authors sued Google, whose parent company is now named Alphabet Inc, in 2005, a year after the project was launched. But Google argued that the effort would actually boost book sales by making it easier for readers to find works, while introducing them to books they might not otherwise have seen. A lawyer for the authors did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Google had said it could face billions of dollars in potential damages if the authors prevailed. Circuit Judge Denny Chin, who oversaw the case at the lower court level, dismissed the litigation in 2013, prompting the authors’ appeal. Chin found Google’s scanning of tens of millions of books and posting “snippets” online constituted “fair use” under U.S. copyright law.

Source

NOTE: TECHi Two-Takes are the stories we have chosen from the web along with a little bit of our opinion in a paragraph. Please check the original story in the Source Button below.

Balanced Perspective

TECHi weighs both sides before reaching a conclusion.

TECHi’s editorial take above outlines the reasoning that supports this position.

More Two Takes from Reuters

Pentagon to Add Alibaba Baidu BYD to China Military List Impact on Business and Markets
Pentagon to Add Alibaba Baidu BYD to China Military List Impact on Business and Markets

The Pentagon plans to add Alibaba, Baidu, and BYD to its list of Chinese companies linked to the military.  This…

Nvidia Fights Back Against Critics on $4.5 Trillion Valuation
Nvidia Fights Back Against Critics on $4.5 Trillion Valuation

Nvidia is pushing hard against doubters like Michael Burry, the Big Short star, who question its sky-high value.  The company…

FAA Probes Amazon After Prime Air Drone Cuts Internet Cable in Texas
FAA Probes Amazon After Prime Air Drone Cuts Internet Cable in Texas

Amazon is currently under investigation by the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) following an incident where one of its delivery…

Starlink’s Direct-to-cell Service Launches in Ukraine in European First
Starlink’s Direct-to-cell Service Launches in Ukraine in European First

The launch of Starlink’s direct-to-cell service in Ukraine indicates a moment when technology goes beyond mere convenience, it becomes a…