Australia considers a “graduated response” system to help curb online piracy

TECHi's Author Connor Livingston
Opposing Author Techdirt Read Source Article
Last Updated
TECHi's Take
Connor Livingston
Connor Livingston
  • Words 66
  • Estimated Read 1 min

Australia is edging toward a “graduated response” system after the attorney-general declared his country’s government would consider such measures to help curb online piracy. George Brandis, who serves in the dual role of attorney-general and minister for the arts, told a gathering last Friday he was committed to a major overhaul of the country’s Copyright Act, to bring the laws up-to-speed with new technologies. 

Techdirt

Techdirt

  • Words 93
  • Estimated Read 1 min
Read Article

We’ve repeatedly pointed out how graduated response anti-piracy programs don’t slow piracy. France’s Hadopi program is obviously example A, though here in the United States our own graduated response program, where users are either throttled or bombarded with one-sided “educational” materials, has proven equally ineffective at impacting piracy rates. This shouldn’t have really been much of a surprise, considering that numerous studies have shown that such programs really don’t work and can in some cases have significant negative implications; studies that the entertainment industry and governments promptly ignore. 

Source

NOTE: TECHi Two-Takes are the stories we have chosen from the web along with a little bit of our opinion in a paragraph. Please check the original story in the Source Button below.

Balanced Perspective

TECHi weighs both sides before reaching a conclusion.

TECHi’s editorial take above outlines the reasoning that supports this position.

More Two Takes from Techdirt

OpenStreetMap wants to crowdsource a map of the Amazon
OpenStreetMap wants to crowdsource a map of the Amazon

Crowdsourced mapping is can be very helpful in many places, but it has the most potential in areas that haven't been…

Numerous FISA judges are also Verizon shareholders
Numerous FISA judges are also Verizon shareholders

It looks as if the judges who operate the gateway between the NSA and the cable companies may not be…

Congress just dealt a massive blow to municipal broadband
Congress just dealt a massive blow to municipal broadband

US Representative, Marsha Blackburn, wants to make sure the Federal Communications Commission never interferes with a "state's right" to protect…

Microsoft made a “technical error” while hijacking someones else’s network
Microsoft made a “technical error” while hijacking someones else’s network

Microsoft admitted Tuesday it made a technical error after it commandeered part of an Internet service’s network in order to…